Key Takeaways:
After a domestic violence arrest in California, you are booked, held, and brought before a judge within 48 hours. Before that hearing, you may be handed a court order barring you from your own residence, your phone contacts, and sometimes your children. Breaking that order, even by answering a single text message, creates a second criminal case.
Most people arrested during a domestic dispute have never seen the inside of a jail, and the pace of those first days is disorienting. At Hurwitz Law Group, our criminal defense attorneys move forward with these cases while the police report is still being sent to the district attorney's office. Call our team and ask what the coming days are likely to look like in your situation.
California does not leave the decision to arrest to the people involved in the incident. Under Penal Code 13701, every law enforcement agency must adopt written policies that encourage arrest whenever officers have probable cause to believe a domestic violence offense occurred. Those same policies require an arrest, absent exigent circumstances, when an officer has probable cause that an existing protective order was violated.
A widespread myth holds that this state mandates an arrest on every domestic violence call. The statute is narrower than that, and the difference matters to your defense. Officers still exercise judgment at the scene, and the record of how they exercised it can be examined later.
The same statute directs officers to make reasonable efforts to identify the dominant aggressor, defined as the most significant aggressor, rather than the first. In making that determination, an officer must weigh the history between the parties, threats that created fear of physical injury, and whether either person acted in self-defense. Dual arrests are discouraged, though they are not prohibited.
Nothing in that process gives the person who called 911 control over what follows. Prosecutors, not callers, decide whether a case moves forward.
The hours after an arrest follow a predictable sequence, even though it rarely feels orderly from inside a holding cell. Knowing the order of events helps you recognize which moments actually carry weight.
Several stages follow in roughly this order:
Each stage generates a record that a defense attorney can later request and examine.
Timing is set by statute rather than by local practice. Penal Code 825 requires that you be taken before a magistrate without unnecessary delay and within 48 hours of arrest, excluding Sundays and holidays. Weekends and court holidays can stretch that two-day rule into four or five actual days in custody.
An emergency protective order (EPO) is the fastest restriction available under state law. Under Family Code 6250, a judge or magistrate can issue an EPO 24/7 at an arresting officer's request—without prior notice to you and without a court hearing.
The order becomes legally enforceable the moment you are personally served in custody or upon release. Under Family Code 6256, an EPO remains active until the close of judicial business on the 5th court day or 7th calendar day after issuance, whichever comes first.
The restrictions that attach during those first days commonly include the following:
Violating any term of an active EPO is an independent misdemeanor under Penal Code 273.6, punishable by up to one year in county jail. Prosecutors can and will file separate PC 273.6 charges if you break an EPO, even if the District Attorney ultimately declines to file charges on the original domestic violence arrest.
If an order was served on you today, call Hurwitz Law Group at (323) 244-4147 before you return to the residence, answer a message, or explain your side to anyone.
An arrest and a criminal charge are two different events, and many people treat them as one. Officers arrest. The district attorney's office decides afterward, sometimes weeks later, whether to file a complaint, reduce the allegation, or decline the case.
At arraignment, the judge informs you of any filed charges, takes your plea, and addresses the terms of your release. Nearly everyone pleads not guilty at this stage, which preserves every option that follows. The court will also commonly issue a criminal protective order, which Penal Code 136.2 authorizes while a criminal case is pending.
Release conditions are also set here. A judge may release you on your own recognizance, set bail, or impose conditions such as counseling enrollment or restricted contact. Those terms govern your daily life until the case ends.
Sometimes, no charge is filed at all. A case can close at the filing stage when the available evidence does not support the elements a prosecutor would have to prove in court.
Two statutes account for most domestic violence filings in this state. Which one applies to the complaint depends largely on whether the other party sustained a visible physical injury.
Domestic battery covers unwanted force used against a spouse, cohabitant, former spouse, fiancé, dating partner, or the other parent of your child. No injury is required for this charge, and the offense is always a misdemeanor. Penal Code 243(e)(1) sets a fine of up to $2,000, county jail of up to one year, or both.
Where the court grants probation, it must also order a batterer's treatment program lasting at least one year.
Corporal injury requires a traumatic condition, which under California law can be as minor as a visible bruise, scratch, swelling, or redness. Penal Code 273.5 is a wobbler offense, meaning prosecutors have complete discretion to file it as a misdemeanor or a felony depending on the severity of the injury, prior record, and early defense intervention.
A felony conviction carries a sentence of 2, 3, or 4 years in state prison. A misdemeanor conviction carries up to one year in county jail and fines up to $6,000.
Probation carries strict statutory terms in these cases. Under Penal Code 1203.097, if you are granted probation for a domestic violence offense against an intimate partner, California law mandates a minimum 36-month probation period, an explicit statutory requirement that overrides standard probation duration caps. Mandatory terms include a formal protective order, community service, a minimum $500 fine, and mandatory enrollment in a 52-week batterer’s intervention program.
Early work shapes what a prosecutor sees before the filing decision gets made. We gather the material that an arrest report leaves out.
Officers reach that conclusion in minutes, under pressure, working from partial information. Our attorneys examine whether both parties were interviewed separately, whether injuries on our client were photographed, and whether prior incidents were genuinely checked.
Self-defense evidence is frequently missing from an initial report. When it exists, we document it and present it to the filing deputy.
Body-worn camera footage, 911 audio, and jail call recordings are retained for surprisingly short periods. Our team sends preservation requests early so that those recordings survive long enough to be reviewed.
Text threads, photographs, and messages from the days surrounding the incident also matter. We collect them while timestamps and metadata remain intact.
Where the facts support it, we contact the district attorney before charges are filed and present what the report omitted. That conversation cannot guarantee a result, though it does put a fuller picture in front of the person making the decision.
No. The district attorney owns the charging decision, and a request to drop the case is only one factor a prosecutor weighs.
The arrest can still appear on your record even when the prosecution declines to file. We can review what record relief may be available once the filing window closes.
Not on your own. Ask the court or arrange a law enforcement escort first, because returning without one risks a new criminal charge.
Self-defense is a recognized defense, and it also bears on which person officers should have identified as the dominant aggressor. Tell us before you tell anyone else.
It can. These orders sometimes include temporary custody and visitation terms that stay in force until a court revisits them.
No. A no-contact order restrains you regardless of who reaches out, and a single reply can support a separate criminal case.
If an officer has already decided you were the dominant aggressor, that determination is not the end of the discussion. Understanding what happens after a domestic violence arrest is one thing; having someone act on it before charges are filed is another.
Hurwitz Law Group is a criminal defense firm serving clients across California, and its founding attorney, Brian Hurwitz, has more than 10 years of criminal defense experience. Our team requests the recordings, reads the arrest report closely, and speaks with the filing deputy where the facts support doing so.
We will evaluate your situation honestly and explain the options actually available to you. Reach out for a free case evaluation before your arraignment date, not after.
Call our domestic violence defense attorneys at (323) 244-4147 or contact us through our contact page to schedule your free case evaluation.
Search
Categories
Brian Hurwitz Has 10+ Years of Criminal Defense Experience
Affordable Fees and Payment Plans
We Offer No-Cost, Confidential Phone Consultations
